Deep Dive on New Apple TV 4K with Sigmund Judge
Download MP3Hello and welcome to a special episode of
Primary Technology.
I'm one of your hosts, Stephen Robles,
joined by award winning co host Jason Aten.
How's it going, Jason?
Good. I've never felt like I was gonna
learn more than what's about to happen.
I don't even know what's gonna happen,
What's about to happen?
but I feel like I'm gonna learn a lot.
I'm really excited to talk to our special
guest today.
He is a longtime reporter on T VOS Apple
TV.
And while I consider myself a home theater
aficionado,
I see him as like a home theater expert
because he's texting me words I don't even
understand. And so I'm so happy to have
Sigmund Judge on the show for the first
time. Welcome, Sigmund.
Thank you for having me. Long time
listener,
first time caller.
Mm-hmm.
Very good.
And Sigmund Judge is in the UK.
And I just want to start real quick
because we're going to get into
the new Apple TV 4K. I have many questions
because you really know the ins and outs
of the hardware. You were texting me
things that I didn't understand.
We've been texting a lot the last couple
weeks with the new Apple TV 4K.
And I asked you about your setup.
And you said some words I understand,
like Dolby Atmos 7.4.2 and all of that.
And then you said other things like
Trinov.
system. I don't know what that is.
So can you tell me what your current setup
is and what is this incredible new thing
you're gonna be doing soon?
Okay, so my current setup is Adobe Atmos
7.4.4 setup.
dot four. my word.
So four subwoofers, four
overhead and seven surround.
But I am in the new year, I mean,
it's all in boxes in the background,
upgrading to a Trinov Altitude system,
which is Trinov is a French company.
They...
specialize in immersive audio and this is
a 20 channel audio processor
so I'm going to 10 bed layer speakers,
four subs, transducers and up top six
speakers
for the Atmos. So
Sigmund,
you're my you're my hero. You are my
aspirational theater setup.
The Trina I I mean, when people mention
audio gear and video gear I've never heard
of, I know they're like the real deal.
And so this is wild. Now you have a
projector running all of this.
Is that accurate?
I've got an Epson LS12000B. um So it's a
4K.
It's not a native 4K player,
but yeah, it gives a really good image.
130 inch screen. um
All now you're just showing off.
All right, all right, all right.
That's that is amazing. And because you
sent me I asked I was asking you Dolby
Atmos as I was talking about the TV
Mm-hmm.
and you sent me a short video clip and I
said,
wait a minute, what is happening here?
Because it just looked like a massive
screen and you were just lounging
in uh the luxury of your home theater.
So that's super fun. Very super fun.
So I wanted to ask you first, high level,
first impressions the new Apple TV four K
is out there.
You've had it for a few days. You
upgraded from the previous gen.
The third gen four K? Okay. Yeah,
Yes? yeah, yeah,
yeah, yeah. And do have you noticed as an
official as an expert,
what have you noticed different in the new
four K?
Not a lot. um It's the Apple TV is.
Jason, calm down.
I didn't say anything.
Okay, okay,
go ahead. I'm sorry, go ahead.
It's,
it's Zippier,
Zipier. Yeah.
definitely. em But I haven't seen any like
app performance.
I mean, there are a few, a few moments
where like you might get some dropped
frames in the animations and that kind of
thing as we were getting to,
you know, em TVOS 27 kind of introduced
some of that.
That's gone.
Right.
Also, if you've got big collections in
your TV library,
I for years used to struggle with an Apple
TV just loading
up my large library of purchases.
And I don't have that issue at all.
It's instant. It's amazing in that regard.
um Obviously,
you know, the things that have been part
of the promotion.
Right? Siri AI is sometimes really good
and really conversational.
And sometimes it just reminds you that
you're talking to Siri again,
because some of the ways in which you may
ask for something.
If I ask for, you know, when's the next
train from my local train station
to Victoria? It can't tell me.
But if I say the name plus station at the
end,
it will.
is that those kind of things that I feel
like still need some work.
I was honestly hoping to see some kind of
software overhaul with
the new hardware to a degree. um And what
I would say is what this
does give me is hope.
And I mean, if I'm honest,
you beyond beyond that. And if you lose
your remote,
I never do. So it's never been a thing.
But you have that now. And. Yeah,
I mean, we're getting to HomePod Surround.
Mm-hmm.
We can get into HomePod Surround.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Glowing glowing
review. I'm curious with Siri AI,
have you found any TV specific use cases
that you've actually used more than once?
Like when I was making my video,
asking it where a movie was filmed,
that was fun. You know, you can ask about
actor,
actress information. That's interesting.
I've done I don't do it a ton,
but it's fun that it's there. Is there any
use case where you're like,
okay, this on the Apple TV is cool,
makes sense?
I think it makes sense on a trivia point
of view.
You know, if you want to know something
quick,
yeah, yeah.
that's really cool. Couple of examples
when I was watching the studio,
I was asking like
Yeah, yeah.
on that episode when
yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
they're driving in the car. I wanted to
know what that car was.
I asked.
Oh.
It told me.
gave me that information,
Okay.
which was great. But also the information
isn't specific to Apple TV shows,
you know, when it comes to Siri,
which is great. Of course, Insight,
which basically works alongside Shazam,
right, to dig out those tracks for you.
That is still limited to Apple originals.
Yeah.
In the way that Apple do it.
If you're asking for context on screen,
so maybe you like Seth Rogen's glasses and
you want to know what they are,
when you ask Siri, it will say,
well, there are no glasses. All I see is a
black screen due to DRM.
So I'm hoping that limitation can at least
be removed for Apple and partners
to be able to work into Siri AI.
So s
That would be cool.
so wait so are you saying when I a if I'm
watching a piece of content,
like when I was watching Dune Park Two and
I asked the voice assistant where was this
filmed? It's not actually looking at the
content on screen,
it's just kind of looking at the movie
information itself.
That's right.
Oh, that's unfortunate. Okay.
Yeah, so, you know, there's a little bit
of jiggery-pokery going on.
The interesting thing for me with regard
to Siri AI,
though, is what is coming. So I think you
and Jason have talked about it before
with regard to 27.3 coming and what that's
going to open up to third-party
developers.
Yeah, that's true.
I already know third-party developers that
make some incredible apps.
And especially when it comes to like Plex
and Jellyvin apps,
that kind of thing,
Mm-hmm.
they're ready to go once RC hits and that
becomes public and they're ready
to distribute, they're ready to tie into
that system,
which I think is going to be a game
changer for us.
And I think.
just kind of looking into the future
because there isn't much with this release
right now. Looking into the future,
think Siri AI and Apple TV could actually
be really cool for calling up certain
things. So we'll get into it with like
pass-through audio in a second,
no doubt.
Yeah, yeah.
Apple TV can't do pass-through audio.
But if you had a device that could,
you could potentially build an app
where you can call that request,
get your cinema to switch over,
and
Hmm. And then do it.
still use the smarts of Apple TV to get
the things that maybe
are limited on the box itself.
Yeah.
Well, okay, I want to back up.
Cause you've been saying a lot of words I
don't understand for this whole time.
Steven's Steven only gets
I'm sorry.
them in tech no, you're fine I'm just
kidding.
Mo I'm mostly kidding. Uh I I wanna ask
well,
first of all, we're violating all sorts of
my orthodoxy here,
which is like I I don't ever want my Apple
TV box to be listening to me for anything.
And I was I I did
Mm-hmm.
listen to the what is it, Smart Home
Insider?
Is that the episode that you d Okay,
Yeah, smart home and center with Andrew,
yeah.
yeah.
And you know, talking about how like that
was
part of the expense most likely of why
this box got more expensive was those
microphones. And I feel like Apple has
stuck so many things in our homes that
have microphones. What is the actual
advantage?
Like why couldn't I just talk to my watch,
which in my opinion is the only thing that
should be listening to you for Siri
and and have it show up on the TV?
Like these things are connected anyway.
So like I don't necessarily think we need
another thing to shout at.
So I in your experience, is that worth it?
Like is it is it something that I also
just to be honest,
I really
Cannot imagine how crazy I will go if I
put one of these in my living room
and my children start shouting at the TV
all the time.
Like I'm going to lose my mind.
Sure.
I think, like, so for me, I would turn it
off because I've tried a couple of things.
Like, for example, if I'm playing a show
or a film and I ask out loud
for the show to pause, it will pause.
When I ask it to play...
it plays Apple Music and doesn't continue
playing the film that I have on my screen.
nice.
So
there's lots of limitations that have come
over from Siri with HomePods,
which have been, you know, you've been
able to connect HomePods to an Apple
TV for forever for voice control.
None of that's been fixed. And I think
that was announced in 2017.
So.
Sure.
And you know, the thing that seems to work
almost every time is that button
on the remote that you just play,
pause. Like it still
Exactly.
works every time.
Pretty reliable.
The thing that I think beyond that though
is it is nice for,
if it were to work and just do the basics,
I think it would be great for older
people.
I think there's ways in which with
Homeview,
for example,
Apple could really change the way in which
this new era of streaming has kind
of missed a generation
Hm.
that still stick with linear TV because
all the different UI is different
and scary in a sense and just alien.
I've kind of thought about it in the sense
of like with HomeVue,
I picked one up at the same time that I
picked Apple TV up.
There's no remote.
app on the home view right now.
So it feels like that could be a perfect
control center in a living room.
It's great for music playback and that
kind of thing,
but it could be a control center.
You could go further.
in the sense of there's enough RAM and an
Apple TV and a home view.
If they were to talk to one another,
maybe there could be some kind of
conversion where everything kind of stays
the same, like the old Apple TVs where
every app had the same layout.
If there was a way of being able to
convert that so that navigating these apps
was easier for older people or just in
general,
just accessible to everyone. So there's
lots.
that these devices could do. They just
don't do them
Yeah.
yet.
Well, one of the I think the biggest
feature of the new Apple TV is the home
pod surround. And I've tried it multiple
setups I talked about in my review.
You know, it's good. Lacks a subwoofer.
We could talk about hacking a subwoofer
into the system in a moment.
But how did you compare? How did you feel
about the,
you know, four home pod surrounds?
Did you use the let me know if you used
the big one,
the minis, and what configuration,
and just that compared to your wild home
theater setup that you already have?
Absolutely. So I've got four of the big
HomePod second generation,
which I got to say the first generation of
the big HomePod sounds so much better than
the second from a yeah,
It would have had more base too for like
movies and stuff.
Ha ha.
yeah,
Yeah.
just just a better signature. But the
HomePod 2's pair just two are fantastic.
And I'm really happy that they've made
this available now for HomePods.
However,
Um, for me, I love the fact that this is
available to people and it's a simple
way of being able to do it. Um,
especially if you don't have room for a
sensor channel,
maybe you're using a projector system and
you don't have a transparent screen,
right? Acoustically transparent screen.
That's a, that's an issue, right?
In a lot of setups. So this home pod
system is pretty good in that sense
in terms of ease of use.
Sound wise though, and this seems to be a
quirk.
So when you have two HomePods connected,
you are getting spatial Dolby Atmos.
When you connect four HomePods,
you're getting this new surround sound
from Apple,
Hmm. Hmm.
right?
And they sound different to me.
um There's definitely better separation
when using just two and getting Dolby
Atmos.
em or you know that Fode-Obey atmosphere.
And so I actually prefer two HomePods
rather than the four
but I think for those that maybe don't
have as keen an ear and this is their
first foray into Surround, it's pretty
good.
Yeah.
It's pretty good. I've been t we've been
texting a lot because again,
I'm I'm an aficionado, not an expert,
but I knew Dolby Atmos is what I want
everywhere because as opposed to like
separating channels from front,
rear and surrounds, Dolby Atmos technology
is like we're gonna place this sound
spatially in the room here. So if there's
like a laser blast from Star Wars
or whatever, the designers of the Dolby
Atmos
you know, sound of a movie can say we're
gonna put that in this location in a room.
And that's what Dolby Atmos is about.
And Apple TV actually tells you when it's
playing Dolby Atmos,
even apart from your receiver or other
like hardware.
So when you're watching a movie in Apple
TV or maybe some shows,
but mostly a movie, if you pull up the
info card while the movie's playing,
which shows you like the title and the
overview,
there's these little tags at the bottom.
And you might see Dolby Vision,
Dolby Atmos, or something else,
like HD, something, something.
And those are live. And this was one of
the things you texted me was like a video
of you yourself having the Atmos active.
You see the Dolby Atmos tag while you're
watching the movie.
And then you went back to the settings,
disabled Atmos, went back to the movie,
pressed play, and that tag is gone.
So those are live. And that was that was
news to me.
I always thought those tags were just what
is the movie capable of?
Which is true on the movie title screen,
uh, but when you're actually watching the
movie,
those tags respond to what audio is c
coming through your speakers.
Is it Dolby Atmos or something else?
And I noticed no Dolby Atmos when you have
the four big home pods.
And my typical setup is like you know,
I don't know what exactly what you call
it.
There's four in ceiling speakers,
there's two front speakers, a center,
and a sub. Is that five point one point
two or is that seven point one?
Four in the ceiling.
You have anything behind you?
Well, the four like the four in the
ceiling,
two of them are behind me.
Okay, so are you using those as rears or
as Atmos speakers?
Rears and then the middle ones as heights
supposedly.
Okay. Okay. Yeah.
So what is that what is the number?
So 5.2.1.
Yeah.
Okay, yeah, 5.2.1 is what
I have. Yeah. So, you know, and in that
setup,
I surround effect is very clear.
You know, I watched Top Gun Maverick and a
plane flies by,
you know, you you hear it move.
And that was one thing. While the four
home pod setup was good,
I was not hearing that specificity of
location with the four.
Mm-hmm.
But you were saying the two like two home
pods,
which will show you the Dolby Atmos tag.
You found a little bit better spatial
effect with just the two than the four.
So the audio is actually being delivered
in two different ways.
So with Dolby Atmos, just two speakers,
you're getting that channel split between
the two,
right? So that audio split between the
two,
and then they're creating the phantom
image for the center channel to get that
surround, and then they're bouncing off of
things.
The way surround works is...
You actually have the Apple TV sending all
of the audio to all of the speakers.
And then the front left speaker is the
orchestrator.
It's telling the rest, OK, this is your
position and this is what you play from
this track. But they're all receiving
Hmm.
the full track and then they're taking
stuff out.
And I think that may be the reason why it
doesn't sound as good.
Interesting.
because they're not using or at least,
you know, they're not using the spec that
like Dolby Atmos or Sony,
sorry, or Sonos would use, right,
or even the Sony speakers would use to
create
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
this effect. And I think maybe this might
even be old because the patent
for this technology was signed all the way
back in 2017.
So.
wow.
You know, it's been a long time coming for
this feature.
Hmm. Okay. Would you you know in my review
I told people if you wanted to have a nice
surround sound setup, a Sonos Beam
immersive package from Sonos,
which is the Beam Ultra, two Aero 100s as
rears,
and then a submini is actually cheaper
than four big home pods if you were buying
them now. What recomm would that be your
recommendation or how would
you say someone spends sixteen hundred
dollars just for the audio?
I think it's really going to depend on a
case by case basis in the sense of how's
your room set up? It's it's not a you
know,
there's so many edge cases in this.
If you've got a table behind your couch,
then you know, get a couple of HomePod
minis for the back,
a couple for the front. I think you'll be
good.
Sonos. It sounds great.
But I still think there's a little bit of
a barrier
there in terms of ease of use for people
sure.
that I would necessarily recommend the
HomePod set up to.
The sonos system does not play nice with
And I'd probably say four HomePod minis.
Sure.
the Apple TV. Every time I
It doesn't play.
turn something on, I have to turn the
volume back up it from zero every time.
Even if you
Oh yeah.
pause something and you start playing it
again for some reason,
it goes back to zero. And I keep e sending
messages to Tom Conrad and I'm like,
What? Fix this. This is the stupidest
thing in the whole world.
Like my cause when I
I wasn't
had home I replaced my two I have my two
home pods in here and they
Yeah, yeah.
used to be in our living room.
And now we have the sonos system and I'm
like I hate it.
I just wanna j if I c had a place to put
that sonosystem out here instead,
I would switch switch back. It's insane.
Yeah. I was not I was not ready for Jason
to go off on Sotos.
It's just insane.
I mean,
It's fine.
there was a third party developer that had
created an app for controlling sonos from
your Apple TV, but
Yeah.
that's so finicky even still. Like I
appreciate the effort,
but um yeah, I think if you...
You have you have to have a really good
network
for sonos too. Like 'cause there were
times where my I have an arc and a beam
in two different setups. And before I ran
Ethernet to them,
they were when everything was on Wi-Fi,
and maybe it's different now, because this
was like two or three years ago,
it was just connectivity issues.
Sometimes the subwoofer
Mm.
would disconnect and I would have to like
repair it with the Sonos stuff.
Maybe the newer stuff is better,
but once I connected Ethernet specifically
to the sound bars,
I had a much better experience.
But again, now you're talking about way
more complexity than just putting some
home pods.
And I think that's it, right? It's like,
if you just want to set it up and be done,
right? And enjoy this experience that you
haven't experienced at home before,
it's great. Get four HomePod Mini 2s.
Start off with that. See how you get on.
because you can always move them to
secondary positions.
And I think that's the nice thing is like,
okay, if I invest in the Sonos setup,
then, you know, like I've pretty much kind
of figured out,
okay, this is the space for them.
Whereas HomePod Mini 2s, if you decide to
upgrade to the big HomePods later on,
you can just move them and enjoy them
elsewhere.
Yeah. Do you have any home pod twos,
Jason? Home pod mini twos?
No, we have I like forty six home pod
minis,
but I mean they're just everywhere.
you
There's uh
there used to be some in here.
I d yeah, we have a lot of them.
But no, we don't have any of the second
Yeah.
gen.
I will just say I've I've I have six of
the second gen,
four review units, two I actually bought,
but my two that are in our master
bathroom,
one of the things my wife does pretty much
every day is just ask what the weather is,
you know, what's the temperature,
what's the high for today? And home pod
mini ones were fine and did that like
eighty percent of the time. Home pod mini
twos incredibly fast sometimes.
Like the other day my wife said,
Hey Dingus, what's the weather today?
And maybe one second later it was actually
responding with the answer.
And that was really surprising.
I don't know if that's actually good
across the board or if it was just that
one instance, but it seems like home pod
mini twos are really good.
And once they get Siri AI, because they
don't have it right now,
that's coming in a software update.
I'm excited for that. Do you have any home
pod mini twos,
Sigmund, that you've tested?
I have tested them, but they're not of
interest to me.
Like once Home View kind of does what I
hoped it would do,
I think that's the way to go for me.
I mentioned before in a previous podcast,
but you know, I also care for my
grandfather.
He needs that kind of visual feedback and
the big buttons for...
turning on and off the lights and that
kind of thing.
you know, yeah.
Home view is the way to go, yeah.
Home view for me, but obviously it's
pricey.
Yeah, yeah. Well let me uh I wanted to ask
you two other audio things because
I I just want to understand them.
A V one that is supposedly new in the new
Apple T V.
Can you tell me what that is? What what
and why do I care?
Okay, that's video. That's video,
Video. it's video, okay.
right? So
it's a new compression format.
Well, actually it's
Okay.
not that new at the moment, but it's
highly used by YouTube,
Netflix, that kind of thing. Actually,
I have seen YouTube performing far better
um on this new Apple TV.
It's not kind
Okay.
of defaulting down to lower resolutions.
Resolutions.
Yeah, yeah.
So
that's very cool. And basically it's a
better compression.
It's open source as well, which means you
don't have to pay license fees for H.264
and H.265. So
Okay.
that...
may help resolve some issues that Disney
had been having with
HDR and 4K and even,
Right.
yeah, all the things in Europe.
Okay.
So that's cool. It's...
It's going to benefit the studio,
the studios and the streaming services
more.
Maybe if you're up for retranscoding your
uh physical media
collection, you can save some hard drive
space.
uh
Gotcha.
But but that's that's pretty much it.
I think it is quite good in the sense of,
you know, if you're in rural areas where
you don't have the best Internet
connection, then you're going to get on
par with.
what everyone else has been experiencing.
So that's good, you know. um
Gotcha.
again, you know, these are are industry
things.
Yes, they're beneficial in certain ways.
I don't know if anyone has like internet
tariffs where the data is capped anymore.
I don't know if that's a thing.
I mean I think if you're on like cellular
stuff in the home,
you know, if you use one of like the the
carrier stuff,
but I
Okay.
have, you know, mediocre speeds here,
just five gigs up and down. So,
you know, it's just sorry.
Don't get started. Don't get I mean,
Just followed.
You
basically
having it is Av like having the A V one
support is just means you know,
like the benefit
or the drawback to it is that it's not
nearly as universal.
Right? It's it's not
Mm.
like not browsers don't all support it the
same way as H dot two six four.
So the Apple T V supporting it natively
just eliminates one of those drawbacks
to A V one support. You know, it's always
a kind of annoying that YouTube that that
was YouTube's native format if you were
using a browser that didn't support
it as well. But now what you're saying is
like if the Apple T V supports that
automatically, like it just means you're
gonna get better performance.
And I I don't know about you, but like I
don't see
Disney plus going back and re encoding
everything.
I I I'm picking at Disney, I'm not I have
no idea,
but like it it's it I don't know if that
juice is worth the squeeze,
but moving forward, knowing that it's
being supported in more places,
because it is a much more efficient
compression format,
right? Like it's like what, sixty percent
or something that of the bitrate?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's, it's, yeah,
full, full, yeah, yeah, around that,
around that. um Yeah,
and, and what I think that will help with
also is being able to,
when you pair that with something like
Dolby AC4,
um that's gonna mean that you're getting
better video
and better audio. That's the promise.
Whereas I think what's going to happen is
the streamers are going to just look
at their bandwidth costs and try and bring
that down to increase profits.
you know, that's a cynical, that's a cynic
in me.
What one other okay, then one other
formatty question.
I saw I think it was Caleb Raid's YouTube
channel when the new T V four K was first
announced, and he talked about everyone
was hoping that audio pass through
was gonna be coming on this new hardware
and that it might be possible it's still
coming in a software update because that's
something Apple has done before with
the T V box where through a software
update enabled something.
What exactly I from my understanding it's
that it would allow like
Right now the Apple T V decodes whatever
audio is is given it from the service
and then pushes it to the audio out,
whether it's your receiver or your now
home pod surround.
And pass through would mean the Apple T V
is not messing with it in the meantime.
Is that an accurate description?
Exactly. It's just
it's passing through that channel,
right? And then
Okay.
letting the processor or the other device
do its thing.
em
Is that a big deal
for you? I mean, you have a amazing setup.
Like, is that something you were hoping
for and maybe hope Apple puts in there?
I've kind of given up on the idea that
Apple would do it purely because I don't
see how it makes and ties into their
business model.
and again, I mentioned it a few moments
ago,
Dolby AC4, right? It was trialed last year
by Peacock during the World Cup.
And it's this newer compression.
This newer audio format that is designed
for immersive audio as opposed
to this Dolby Digital Plus, which is 5.1
and then there's a layer
put on top of it. And it was never really
built from the ground up,
so you wouldn't get the correct levels for
your atmosphere channels and that kind
Gotcha. Okay.
of thing.
And the crazy thing about this newer
format is
A lot of people won't pass through for DTS
HD from their Blu-ray trans
codes and that kind of thing because
that's pretty much other than
ColliderScape, that's pretty much the only
place you can get that.
DTS HD is contrived from linear PTM,
right? So that's the master file.
And this Dolby AC4 at 480 kilobits per
second rather than
the 16 megabits per second of linear PTM.
em It sounds almost identical.
So it beats the pants off of DTS HD.
audio, which
I see
is what everyone is asking for,
right? Because that's why people want
pass-through.
I see. Right.
So
I'm waiting for that next step.
And I think Apple and the industry are
waiting.
And 84 is starting to roll out to live
broadcasts more and more this year.
Gotcha.
You know, this is a long stage,
but then there's also licensing with
Dolby,
right?
Mm.
How
much do they get a charge? Can everyone
cut a deal and make it the new standard?
Mm-hmm.
Gotcha. Okay. All right. Well,
that's thank you for for breaking that all
down.
That's super fun. I want a couple just
last questions because I you're the only
one that I know would know. T V OS twenty
seven introduced smart downloads.
And as far as I can tell, like you can
turn this setting on,
and then I have no idea what happens after
that.
Do you have he's already shaking his head.
Have you had any experience
No, no, and.
like
Mm-hmm. What is it? Like have you seen it?
Like have you seen what it does anywhere?
No. And I would
Okay, great.
love for
Good good good talk.
Ha ha.
the Apple, I would love for the project
manager for Apple TV to do interviews
Yeah. Yeah.
like they did
for Homeview and whatnot. Because
actually,
Apple, come on. We got ya.
is the products that people don't want to
nerd out on,
And understand what it
Yeah.
does, what it doesn't, right? And
especially at the price point,
right?
So, um,
Right.
yeah, so no, I believe that
Okay, great.
feature is specifically for iOS,
right? But again, no, no one's told us
it's a
But it's on the T Apple TV. Like you you
can go to the setting
on your Apple TV and it's right there.
I just don't know. Like supposedly it will
maybe.
This is the only thing I've read.
I think it like in a support document,
that maybe if you're watching something
like an Apple TV plus show or some
TV show, maybe it would download the next
episode so that when you're watching
and it goes to the next one, it'll do it.
But I don't even know like it nothing
explicitly says that.
And I I'd
And how,
mean, I mean, this is the thing,
right? I kept it secret, but how cool a
story would this be,
right? You could wrap this into the eco em
story,
right? em And say, we've checked to see
when the cleanest energy is being
produced in your home, in your area,
right? And based on that, we'll download
ready for your
up next queue.
when you come up so that not everyone is
sucking the energy and using the bandwidth
of the ISP at the same time, right?
So there's a cool story that could be
told,
but again, we don't know.
Yeah. Jason, you have no I mean yeah yeah.
Well, I have a question. I don't uh you
have other like norm normie questions,
but my question because no no no no that I
meant that in a good way.
Wow. Wow. No, I know. I know.
Well, they're like nerd normie.
But my you
Exactly.
have mentioned twice now, Sigmund,
you talked about like what would fit
Apple's business model and just
my my question on this is like this is a
three hundred dollar streaming box.
It is in
Hmm?
my opinion, the best streaming box that
most people would even consider.
Right. There are there may be them there's
this
weird thing that Steven bought that like
is ridiculous.
The collidescape. The collidescape.
But yeah, that thing.
But most people are not considering that.
That's that's not an option for most
people.
You got one too, right? You have one too.
That's great.
I'm I'm so happy for you both.
I have the Stratocade, so it's incredible.
I'm I'm so happy for both of you.
But most people
You
are never gonna consider that.
And that's fine. Like but that's not what
Apple's going after.
And yet it because it is such a good
streaming box,
it is confusing.
Because it's great quality, it's easy for
people to use.
It's way, way overpowered for what you
need for it.
So it's like I have I have Apple TVs in my
house.
I have no idea how old they are.
They're black. That's the I mean,
I have one Apple TV that's like the
original.
We don't use it anymore. But like it's
great.
Still works, still supported.
It's yeah, I if I plugged it in,
it
probably would still work. Uh
Yeah. Yeah.
it's been in a box for a very long time.
So it's possible that the spinning hard
drive bearings are are just completely
euchred at this point. But
you
But it's you it the the thing that's like
kind of confusing is it works the best
if you just stick with Apple's system.
If you stick with the home pods,
if you stick with whatever. We use them
with home pods in a lot of places.
But then we get to the Sonos, we've got an
uh arc and then we've got a sub.
And then in here I've got one and it's got
these two K E F L S fifty wireless,
which are like the best speakers that I
own and fantastic speakers.
But the air The exactly. But then it's
like
I'm Kev. I'm Kev Everywhere.
Yeah, yeah see, yeah.
But the but the Apple TV is like,
what what is this? I mean, they're
airplay,
so it's it's fine, but it's like,
uh, what are you doing? It's and so my my
thing is like it is hard for me to know
where this thing fits. And the reason I'm
asking about this is the $300 price.
Until this year, it was the easiest thing
to recommend to anyone who asks me.
My parents bought a new house,
they were putting a TV, and he's like,
Can I just run all the stuff off the TV?
I'm like, I will never come over if you do
that.
Just plug in an Apple TV.
Turn
off the Wi Fi on your television itself
and just you'll be so happy.
And but now that price gets a little bit
more complicated because it's like it's
pushing up there against the most
expensive streaming box that most people
would be considering. Well, no,
it's it is absolutely the most expensive
streaming box anybody's gonna actually
consider. But it also doesn't play nice
with all the other things that they might
want to do. And I just I'm like the home
view is kind of the same way,
Steven. We talked about this. It's like
it's it's you gotta really care about
smart home stuff to want a home.
Yeah.
a home view, but also doesn't do all the
things you want it to do.
I don't know, Sigmund, what do you think?
Like what is Apple trying to do with the
Apple T V?
I think that Apple TV is in a good spot.
Um, not in terms of cost. I,
I've just got a funny feeling that
obviously we,
waited a number of years for this.
We've heard the rumors of delays and this
Four hundred. It's been a long time.
kind of thing, right? Four years,
right? Um, I've just got a funny feeling
that the project probably
was of a different time.
and then when it came to actually
manufacturing,
the costs grew significant. Now,
the good stuff for me is I've always
wanted an Apple TV Pro.
This isn't it, but it's in the price point
that I would have expected an Apple
TV Pro to be, which
Right. Yes.
means now that we could possibly have two
tiers because I think this is a situation
that Apple will probably like to fix.
em and find a way of being able to bring
the TV app with em and,
you know, third party apps, but maybe not
gaming and that kind of thing.
em You know, bring a similar product
to the market and then allow em for these
Apple TVs that
despite the cost are selling out
everywhere.
mainly because integrators have been
waiting for these new boxes to come
out and they've been buying them by the
boatload.
So I would love to see,
as I kind of explained earlier,
Apple really focus in on the user
experience.
I do feel like when people talk about
Apple TV,
they're talking about the great shows.
They're talking about the content rather
than user experience.
And I think over the last few years,
the user experience has taken a little bit
of a dip in the offices in Cupertino
and really kind of more pandered for the
traditional television and film execs.
uh in Los Angeles that they hired from
Sony and elsewhere.
And so I would love to see them really
start to think more about
accessibility, not in terms of features,
the sign language interpretation that came
is incredible,
Yeah.
uh but more in terms of how can everyone
use this product?
Because the building blocks are there.
Right, right. And I'll just say if
anyone's wondering about that auto
downloads thing, I've been trying to
figure out where the setting was.
If you go on your Apple TV to settings and
then you go to apps,
there is the toggle for automatically
download in app content.
And if you turn that on, let me know if
anybody sees anything different.
If anything changes once you enable this
setting,
because that's the supposed smart
downloads and I I don't know what it does.
I turned it on.
Steven, can't
Can I just
ask you?
you can't you sniff the packets
on your network to see if anything's going
on here,
Steven?
yeah, that's a good
I should try and do that actually.
I might do that. Go ahead, Sigma.
Whilst you do, that's the new Apple TV,
right?
No, the one y no, the that was a video
from T V OS twenty seven.
That was the latest the third gen four K
right there.
Okay, this is the third gen 4k?
I think so. On TV OS twenty seven,
Okay,
but yeah.
so one thing I was going to say was one
little detail.
When I was setting up my new Apple TV,
em when you get to set up with iOS,
it actually came up with the image for the
Apple TV from two generations back that
actually had TV on top of it. And...
Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Nice.
When you go into the settings on this new
generation,
it shows the older image as well.
The newer, the third generation had its
image changed to reflect
the actual box. So details,
Cool. Cool.
details. I
feel like I'm moaning a lot, but I just,
love this platform.
You're
on the right
show, it's fine.
That means you're on Jason's side.
That's what that means. All right.
Well, here's my my last question to you,
Sagan. Thank you so much for for sharing
your expertise.
And I want to follow up maybe when we get
some of these updates and uh sooner than
four years from now when we get our new
Apple T V four K.
Sorry, before your last question,
did you want
Yeah.
to talk about how we've hooked up
subwoofers?
yes, yeah. So one of the things I said in
my review,
and you mentioned too, is you know,
having four even the big home pods,
you lack the subwoofer, the low end.
And thankfully, you can still add airplay
speakers when you have the new home
pod surround setup. You can still go to
the control center and add them.
And so you were talking about doing this
with an airport express,
which I love. I couldn't find my old one.
So I didn't do that. But I got this,
which is the Wii P
Pro. It is made to just add airplay
functionality to your whatever speakers,
bookshelf speakers and stuff. It's 170
bucks.
It's way too much to do this. You know,
maybe get an airport express is probably
better.
But you know, you can connect to the
Ethernet.
It has, you know, RCA red and white
connections,
also has coax, it has optical audio.
But all I did was connect this to my KEFS
or my Clipsh subwoofer and
When I was playing on the Apple TV,
added the Wii Pro as an airplay,
an additional speaker, and now I had four
big home pods plus my big subwoofer.
And it was closer to the experience I'm
hoping for when watching home theater
because it's a nice low end, you get the
big bass.
But I like you were mentioning,
I've I've found it to be a little less
focused or less uh optimized
for the subwoofer because the Apple TV is
just sending the
an airplay signal to the sub as though it
is a regular speaker,
not a subwoofer. And that's been your
experience trying this out?
Mm Yeah. But I think it's cool that it can
be done.
I also think it's cool that home view um
if you use that as a as another channel,
obviously you can have the sound coming
through that.
But then you can actually connect air pods
to your home view.
So if you're in a household where maybe
there are people that have a hard
of hearing. m
They can put those in, hear the dialogue
without you having to blast everything.
Another thing just very quickly for
airplay is say for example,
you're watching late at night,
you want to listen on AirPods,
but you want that rumble from your
subwoofer,
right? You could pair the two together
that way.
you could even with a Wimpro if you got
transducers and put those in your seats
and you wanted that 4D experience
Ha ha.
you could do that as well so there are
benefits
With your AirPods in.
With your AirPods. That's amazing.
yes it's crazy
but it can be done and you could stack
those home views as well so you could have
a silent cinema in the garden this summer
you know
Wait a minute. Okay, hold hold on second.
So you're saying from the Apple TV,
you're choosing your home views as your
airplay destinations,
and then you're connecting a pair of
AirPods to each home view.
you can connect up to two.
Up to two pairs of AirPods.
Two Yeah.
So you could if you had twenty people,
all you need are ten home views and an
Apple TV,
and then you could have silent cinema for
your garden party this holiday season.
Honestly, that's brilliant.
Absolutely.
This needs to be a video, actually.
I think I need to make Jason's doing the
math.
I'm adding this up right now. Twenty of
these is time sees the show.
Hahaha!
It's
a lot of money, but amazing. And Sigmund,
that's why I enjoy hearing your thoughts
on this because you're thinking of this
wild stuff.
I will say I'd have you ever had like the
vibrating transducer things for bass?
Do you have any of those or you do?
Yes. Yes.
Does
it but wait, is it where you're sitting?
You have it like connected to your chair
or
Mm hmm.
sofa or whatever?
Yeah, yeah. And I had been doing it via
Airplay for a while,
just
It's amazing.
to make it easier because you can just
have them battery operated and
Right, right, right.
then have the amp nearby.
That's amazing.
Yeah, you can have real fun.
with this and and that's what I would say
is you know yes they're edge cases
um but there's that's what is nice about
apple tv and airplay and this kind
of thing okay might not be the creme de la
creme right um but it's
gonna open up so many things as long as
you get inventive
Yeah.
That's fun. All right, Sigma, my last
question for you.
What are you watching? You have this
amazing system.
You know you're all about Apple T V and
stuff,
but what what are some recent series that
you've enjoyed watching?
Maybe your favorite Apple T V plus series?
Well not plus anymore, just regular Apple
TV series.
What are you watching?
Okay, Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed is a
crazy show.
I loved it. Really kooky comedy.
If you liked Search Party, which was on
HBO,
I forget what it was before that,
this is just a fantastic show.
It's not the kind of show that I ever
thought Apple would put out,
Hm.
because
it is really off the wall, but a lot of
fun.
I saw at London Film Festival,
I went to the European premiere for Being
Human,
which has just come out on Apple TV.
It's fantastic. em Really,
really good. And of course you have that
em sign language interpretation,
which isn't just, em it is an
interpretation,
right? It's not just a conversion,
so to speak, or translation,
Right, right.
which is very cool. em
In terms of games and stuff, uh sketch
party.
uh It's an
Mm.
old, old game, right? It actually got some
stage time back in the day.
Matt Braun develops it and he's just
redesigned and re-
did the game ready for this new Apple TV
launch.
It's really cool. It's basically like a
modern version of Pictionary,
but you use an iPad. It's super cool.
And then I'll just say like in terms of
the most innovative app in the space right
now, for me, especially
if you have a personal server.
It's an app by a London based developer
called Nathan
called Zuno Media Player.
It will aggregate your Plex or your
jellyfin server and that kind of thing,
which is really, really cool. Does the
basics,
but he's redone the audio video engine.
He's using the TV, the Apple TV player.
There are things like watch together.
So uh far.
better implementation of SharePlay,
in my opinion, far more accessible.
And you can SharePlay with downloaded
files em or stream directly altogether.
em He's also included a calendar and iCal
support
for your Up Next and Continue Watching
queue.
Oh.
So when you ask Siri for your daily
breathing,
at least for me right now, I've got all of
the TV shows and movies that are out that
day being told to me. And
That's fun. That's that's fun.
one of the things I thought was,
I use Home Assistant to do this.
Based on playback states, you can...
set automations and scenes. So if I pause
a film late at night,
the lights will come up. That's all been
integrated into his player.
It is crazy work. He's been working on it
full time.
It sounds like an advert, but honestly,
it's so good.
That's super fun. And he's got a lifetime
purchase.
It is free to try. You can try it a bunch.
Then it's two dollars a month,
fifteen a year, or ninety-dollar lifetime.
That sounds super fun though, and it looks
beautiful uh from the app.
And
what I would say is those advanced
features,
if you just want to play back your stuff,
it's free.
That's super fun. Well, Sigmund,
I'm so glad to have you on the show.
We're gonna put links to follow you and
all the things down in the in the show
notes. Go follow Sigmund if you're into
home theater,
Apple T V and you like nerding out.
I just feel smarter when I talk to you
about home theater stuff 'cause I I don't
know about this stuff. So Sigmund,
Thank you so much for having
thanks so much for joining us.
me.
